In a surprising turn of events, even as Vancouver’s City Council entertains notions of becoming a bitcoin-friendly city, British Columbia is sticking steadfast to its province-wide ban on mining BTC, which will remain in place until December 2025.
This ban on bitcoin mining was initiated in December 2022 amid concerns related to energy use, a decision that has faced its share of legal challenges. Conifex Timber, a timber company with interests in BTC mining, contested the ban in court. However, the B.C. Supreme Court upheld the ban in early 2024, underscoring the policy’s strength and its fit with public utility regulations.
Underpinning this decision is BC Hydro, the primary electricity provider in the province, which generates over 90% of its power through hydroelectric means. The irony of a motion to support bitcoin mining in a city heavily reliant on green energy isn’t lost on many—especially since Vancouver’s proposal, led by Mayor Ken Sim, touts the financial advantages of bitcoin, yet lacks the authority to change mining regulations due to the provincial electricity jurisdiction.
In the words of a spokesperson for BC Hydro, “The Province still has a ban on cryptocurrency mining and is continuing its work towards a permanent cryptocurrency mining policy.” This reaffirms the provincial government’s commitment to maintaining control over its energy resources.
Earlier in 2024, the legislature updated the Energy Statutes Amendment Act, originally triggered by BC Hydro’s halting of new bitcoin mining connections to the provincial grid. This updated legislation allows the province to bypass the BC Utilities Commission—the regulatory body governing electricity services—and take direct control over setting regulations specifically for cryptocurrency mining.
Read More: Crypto News Today
Conifex Timber, eager to connect its planned bitcoin mining farms to the grid, challenged the conditions in court, labeling them as “unduly discriminatory and unreasonable.” However, the provincial judge found no merit in their claims.
Legal experts from McCarthy Tetrault, a Canadian law firm, highlighted possible repercussions of the new regulations, questioning whether the province might start to enforce similar electricity regulations for other energy-intensive industries. This adds an interesting layer to the discussion about energy consumption, considering the Leader of the provincial Green Party suggested that industries like Liquified Natural Gas and AI technology should be held to similar energy standards.
It’s interesting to note that while British Columbia enforces its mining ban, other places are navigating alternative paths. For instance, New York State has a moratorium on mining, though it allows exceptions for renewable energy. Conversely, states like Arkansas and Montana are advancing measures to protect bitcoin miners against what they perceive as unfair discrimination. Meanwhile, Pennsylvania has recently lifted its mining ban, seeking to promote other energy conservation initiatives instead.
As the landscape continues to shift—both within British Columbia and beyond—the growing tug-of-war between energy responsibility and the burgeoning interest in bitcoin mining promises to keep the conversation alive. For now, at least in British Columbia, the ban remains firmly in place, leaving potential miners and enthusiasts to ponder what the future may hold.